By Bonnie Honig
Sophocles' Antigone is a touchstone in democratic, feminist and felony concept, and doubtless the main commented upon play within the historical past of philosophy and political concept. Bonnie Honig's rereading of it consequently contains intervening in a number of literatures and unsettling a lot of their governing assumptions. Exploring the facility of Antigone in various political, cultural, and theoretical settings, Honig identifies the 'Antigone-effect' – which strikes those that enlist Antigone for his or her politics from activism into lamentation. She argues that Antigone's personal lamentations could be obvious not only as symptoms of dissidence yet quite as markers of a rival global view with its personal sovereignty and power. Honig argues that the play doesn't provide easily a version for resistance politics or 'equal dignity in death', yet a extra confident politics of counter-sovereignty and team spirit which emphasizes equality in lifestyles.
Read Online or Download Antigone, Interrupted PDF
Similar political theory books
With replies from Judith Butler, Raymond Geuss, and Jonathan Lear.
In the early twentieth century, Marxist idea was once enriched and rejuvenated via adopting the concept that of reification, brought by way of the Hungarian theorist Georg Lukács to spot and denounce the transformation of old procedures into ahistorical entities, human activities into issues that appeared a part of an immutable "second nature. " For a number of purposes, either theoretical and sensible, the hopes positioned in de-reification as a device of innovative emancipation proved useless. In those unique and resourceful essays, added because the Tanner Lectures on the collage of California, Berkeley in 2005, the prestigious third-generation Frankfurt university thinker Axel Honneth makes an attempt to rescue the idea that of reification by means of recasting it by way of the philosophy of popularity he has been constructing over the last twenty years. 3 unusual political and social theorists: Judith Butler, Raymond Geuss, and Jonathan Lear, reply with demanding questions about the crucial anthropological premise of his argument, the belief that sooner than cognition there's a primary adventure of intersubjective popularity which could supply a normative typical wherein present social kin may be judged sought after. Honneth listens rigorously to their feedback and gives a strong protection of his place.
Loose will is a key yet contested inspiration within the paintings of Jean-Jacques Rousseau: whereas the famed thinker is understood to have asserted that loose will distinguishes humans from animals, a number of interpreters have argued that he basically pretends to have this trust for the sake of fit politics and to prevent persecution by way of spiritual experts.
David Fernbach (tr. )
The element of departure of Heide Gerstenberger’s path-breaking paintings is a critique of structural-functionalist conception of the nation, in either its modernisation idea and materialist editions. Prof. Gerstenberger opposes to those a historical-theoretical rationalization that proceeds from the long term structuring impact of concrete social perform. this can be elucidated by way of exact research of the advance of bourgeois nation energy within the key examples of britain and France. different complexions that the bourgeois nation assumed are awarded because the result of approaches of social and cultural formation, and therefore irreducible to an easy functionality of capitalism. This strategy culminates within the thesis that the bourgeois type of capitalist kingdom energy arose purely the place capitalist societies built out of already rationalised constructions of the Ancien Régime type.
"Heide Gerstenberger's comparative learn of the origins and emergence of the bourgeois country in France and England is an bold and provocative paintings. "
--David Parker, historic Materialism
Althusser and His Contemporaries alters and expands realizing of Louis Althusser and French philosophy of the Nineteen Sixties and Nineteen Seventies. millions of pages of formerly unpublished paintings from diverse classes of Althusser's occupation were made to be had in French considering the fact that his dying in 1990. in line with meticulous examine of the philosopher's posthumous courses, in addition to his unpublished manuscripts, lecture notes, letters, and marginalia, Warren Montag presents a thoroughgoing reevaluation of Althusser's philosophical undertaking.
Additional info for Antigone, Interrupted
Indeed, we might see Sophocles’ Antigone as what is left of Achilles in the domesticated democratic polis (and this, I will suggest in Part II, all by itself may be a comment on the post-heroic form of life of ﬁfth-century Athens/Thebes). Both Achilles and Antigone, in love with Patroclus and Polynices, their brother-like lovers or lover-like brothers, cannot stop grieving without being forcibly interrupted. But it is surely important that the interruptions diﬀer: the dance of lament and hunger, pain and pleasure, central to Homeric Greece, is replaced in Sophocles’ Thebes, as in the democratic Athens it mirrors distortedly, by sovereign power.
For Hegel, the function of burial, the purpose of interment (from in terra, literally “in the ground”), is to inter-rupt the natural processes by way of which the dead become organic parts of nature. With the word and deed of ritual, materiality, and speech act, with the stone marker, the cemetery plot, and the coﬃn, with the prayers, eulogies, and rituals for the dead, the family inserts itself into nature’s processes, interrupts them, and claims even the dead for human community. In Hegel, these so-called universals underwrite a contested kinship structure in which it is the sister’s duty to bury the brother.
Meanwhile, the conservative 34 Interruption woman – whose voice is also hard to take, it must be said, but her words are clear to North American audiences – rejects Lipscomb’s focus on her son above all the other US soldiers already lost or still in the ﬁght. And so Lipscomb leaves behind this conﬂict, gives up her ﬂedgling solidarity with the stall-woman, and turns to the White House. Alone and away from the two politicized, equality-centered women in Lafayette Park, Lipscomb returns to her focus on her singular son: “I need my son.
Antigone, Interrupted by Bonnie Honig